The Massachusetts Victory For A"Everyman" Candidate Begs The Question: What's An "Everywoman?"
Friday, January 29, 2010 at 05:11PM I really like this guest post by Nicole Rodgers, originally published in the Huffington Post. Nicole is is a Vice President at Fenton Communications in Washington, D.C. Democratic pollster Celinda Lake has also weighed in on the question of what women candidates can learn from Marthat Coakley's defeat. And in an op ed in the BostonGlobe.com, Ambassador Swanee Hunt and former MA Lt. Governor Kerry Healey say women should "start their campaigns" and not be deterred by any barriers real or perceived. That's why I placed this post into my Courageous Leadership blog, because it is going to take courageous women leaders to keep forging ahead until we reach parity as political decision makers. Let me know what you think.
Scott Brown is from Wrentham, and he drives a truck. He is now a Massachusetts Senator.
This week, as pundits debated whether Brown's win was a referendum on Obama or on health care reform -- and what it says about the "pulse" of the country -- an important discussion about gender was drowned out. Coakley's uninspired campaign produced many legitimate criticisms and it would be unfair to blame her loss on sexism alone. But the typecasting of political actors that electoral campaigns are often reduced to made it nearly impossible for Coakley to succeed in the current political climate. Driving a truck certainly contributed to Brown's win -- but it also solidified Coakley's loss.
Voters want candidates they identify and connect with -- an "everyman" -- and this is particularly evident in the type of populist political moment we are in now. The iconic everyman image remains easy to conjure up: a breadwinning, sports-loving, truck-driving family man who's in touch with the people. Someone who can fight for us because they seem like one of us. Someone like Scott Brown. But while the everyman archetype may be easy to invoke, the "everywoman" politician is far more elusive.
Brown's successful everyman politician, after all, had a familiar playbook: cruising around in his manly but populist vehicle of choice -- a truck; mucking around with an entourage that included popular Boston sports heroes; he's also handsome and strong. A self-described "family man" in a household of women, Brown didn't even have to defend his position on woman's issues. With a wife and two daughters, his dedication to women was apparently self-evident. Brown's TV ad responding to Coakley's attack even featured him in his kitchen -- a traditionally female domain -- with photos of his children plastered across his fridge in the background. It was a dig at Coakley that didn't go unnoticed.
And then there was the now ubiquitous Brown nude centerfold shot in Cosmo. For Brown, it was a funny anecdote -- another colorful detail of his hard-working "everyman" existence (he apparently sought to put his winnings toward his tuition costs at Boston College Law School). These pictures never worked against him; if anything, they certified his masculinity, and certainly his hotness. Could any woman running for Senator have pulled off such a feat?
Martha Coakley, meanwhile, married late and had no children. Although her public service career suggested a deep concern with the welfare of others, she was not thought of as nurturing. She was often accused of being cold, an "ice queen." She was described as "lawyerly" -- though both candidates were lawyers -- and cautious. Said to be too ambitious and opportunistic at the outset of her candidacy, by the end she was not trying hard enough and was described as weak, and lacking the fire in the belly to win. Ultimately, Coakley succumbed to the age-old storyline that pitted her as a detached politics-as-usual elitist running against an underdog everyman.
But what is an iconic everywoman? What does she look like? It's a harder visual to invoke, but certainly one that puts mothering and nurturing at its core. Perhaps Sarah Palin's early dramatic success is the best example of the power of the everywoman image to attract a populist audience. Much like Brown's constant reference to his truck, Palin's acceptance speech at the Republican convention defined her as just a regular hockey mom. Her popularity surged instantly, and only after her startling lack of substance overcame the initial everywoman appeal did it finally ebb.
The truth, of course, is that the very idea of the everywoman is largely inconsistent with the lives of many successful women who run for high office, particularly those of Coakley's generation and older. These women have often had to make more sacrifices than men to succeed in their careers and as a result their lives don't always resemble their male counterparts. Many have spent their professional careers fighting off the stereotype that they are too emotional and soft, and understandably have become wary of showing that side of them. For most male politicians there is a women-behind-the-man who has long supported their careers, raised their kids, and enabled them to "have it all." Women have struggled with this balancing act for decades, so naturally, their lives look different.
Of course, in an ideal world, we wouldn't judge candidates by comically oversimplified labels. We would judge them on their policies, their experiences and their competency to serve. But Martha Coakley may just be the canary in the coal mine warning that women candidates must thread the needle in a way that not only highlights their competence, but also their compassionate, personable side -- particularly during troubled times for the country. Unless we accept this reality -- or hope that the passage of time cements a new vision of an everywoman -- many qualified women candidates will continue to lose.
For women, it's a delicate and often treacherous road to navigate, especially with large trucks barreling on by




Reader Comments (10)
UGG Ultra Short boots
UGG Ultra Tall boots
Ugg Mayfaire Boots
925tiffanyco
925tiffanyblog
925jewelryblog
925royaljewelry
love925silver
discountjewelry
These jerseys men football jerseys which are interestingly termed retro basketball jerseys sports jerseys store are old school. Here is an example,football jerseys for youth men football jerseys, Brazil Team World Cup Soccer Jersey Kobe’s jersey at the present time, but the Lakers look 20 years ago. That would be an example of the throwback kind. Sports stars put them on now and again during games also.
Most of these jerseys NBA basketball jerseys state they’re replicas,Designer Handbags sports jerseys store, yet in fact aren’t. They are the cheapest ones cheap nike shoxmen basketball jerseysout there. They’ve screen imprinted lettering, Women's Handbags additionally are made of the least expensive fabrics availableNike Nike Air Max Shoes.
There is a NFL jerseys discount in nfljeseyonline.com ,I am going to buy one for my younger brother ,he like dressing jersey ,it’s comfortable and release yourself when you take part in excises ,nfl jerseys for kids andThere is a NFL jerseys youth ,and both men and women jerseys ,there are a lots different colors ,such as yellow red green ,as every one know that red stand for good day,it attract me a lot ,I believe in them ,because its There is a nfl jerseys authentic .
Recently I realize that we only have great morals, our society will develop into much more beautiful. I think there have some reason in it. So everyone should make effort to protect our socity. Do you think so? by Air Jordan.
coach outlet
coach outlet
coach handbags
coach factory outlet
coach factory outlet store
coach outlet
Thanks for your sharing! great helpful!!!I am pleased to share my joy with you? 2010-07-22
coach outlet
coach outlet
coach handbags
coach factory outlet
coach factory outlet store
coach outlet
Thanks for your sharing! great helpful!!!I am pleased to share my joy with you? 2010-07-22
Coach outlet store Coach outlet store
Coach outlet Coach outlet
Coach factory outlet Coach factory outlet
Gucci outlet online Gucci outlet online
Gucci outlet Gucci outlet
Gucci handbags Gucci handbags
coach outlet online Coach outlet online
This article is written by zocy003 on 2010-7-23 http://www.coachoutletmalls.com
Tucked away in our timberland for you subconscious is an idyllic vision. We see ourselves on a long trip that timberland 6 inch spans the continent. We are traveling by train. Out timberland hiking boots windows, we drink in the passing scene of cars on nearby highways, of children timberland shoe company waving at a crossing, of cattle grazing on a distant timberland boots hillside, of smoke pouring from a power plant, of row upon row of corn and wheat.