Goldilocks SOTU: Not Too Big, Not Too Small, Just Right
Thursday, January 28, 2010 at 01:12PM "I am feeling so disempowered,” the woman prefaced her question to me at a “Passion to Action” conference in Grass Vally, CA, sponsored by the See Jane Do organization. But her face telegraphed very powerful emotions: anger, frustration, fear. It was a look we’ve seen on the faces of teabaggers as they shouted wild
allegations and disrupted town halls across the nation.
This woman was no teabagger. She was a progressive Democratic woman, a key member of Obama’s base. The impassioned ones who swept him into office on a frothy wave of belief in the change he promised; the ones now feeling somewhere between skeptical and cynical.
“I want real health reform. What happened to that and what can I do about it?” The questioner lobbed this at me after my speech encouraging women to use our power as activists. If hell hath no fury like a woman scorned, then it would be very important to listen to what women like her had to say about Obama’s State of the Union address.
So I went to the discussion boards, the White House Facebook page, Twitter, and posted a query on my own Facebook page to see what my friends were saying about his speech. The focus on jobs and the economy was clearly the top priority for most people and rightly so. Capping government spending, being transparent about who’s getting the pork, becoming a global leader in solar energy, and a tax break for small businesses all got shout outs for being ideas that people appreciated. He apologized elegantly without showing weakness. He said bipartisan twice, enough to keep the centrists and pundits singing his praises, but he also challenged the Republicans to go beyond “no” and help him govern. These were not new initiatives, but we needed to hear them again to know he has not lost his way through the forest of governing.
It was remarkable how, in the absence of bold new goals, even small steps were glommed onto as being big enough. This tells me Obama continues to hold onto a reservoir of goodwill from Americans who truly want their president to be successful.
The folks over at RHRealityCheck were holding a liveblog that included a virtual drinking party. You were supposed to have a drink when certain predictable words or words they wanted to hear were mentioned. Amanda Marcotte said that if abortion were mentioned, she’d guzzle. No worries about Amanda overimbibing tonight.
One woman noted via e-mail that he had used the female gendered pronoun when talking about the need to stimulate small businesses and increase job creation and she appreciated that. I’d noticed it too but it was too small a gesture for me to celebrate.
Another woman posted in response to my Facebook question that his commitment to end Don’t Ask Don’t Tell was big to her, and it is—but didn’t he promise the same thing last year? And still there isn’t a concrete plan or timetable.
In the missed opportunity column, Obama might have seconded the initiative of Senator Chris Dodd (D-Ct) earlier in the day that he will soon schedule a hearing on the Paycheck Fairness Act, a top priority for many women’s groups such as the American Association of University Women.
In fact, Obama mentioned equal pay only in a rhetorical flourish, saying, “We are going to crack down on violations of equal pay laws—so that women get equal pay for an equal day's work.” His other mention of women’s rights was a pledge to support women who march in the streets in Iran and girls trying to go to school in Afghanistan. No concrete promise, such as the U.S. joining the 180 other nations that have ratified CEDAW, and he seems to have completely forgotten his campaign pledge to place the Freedom of Choice Act to codify reproductive rights for women high on his agenda.
Like Goldilocks, he’s not interested in things too big or too small, but perhaps that’s just right for most of the country right now.
The president needed to achieve two things with this speech. First to reclaim his leadership mantle with the general public of voters. The polls show he did that at least for the short term, with 83 percent of those questioned saying they approved of the speech. Seventy percent said after the speech they have the same priorities as the president compared to 57 percent before it. Second, while broadening his message sufficiently for independents, he needed to offer at least one big idea to elevate the spirits of the many people in his base who feel “disempowered” now. That could have come with his focus on jobs. But it didn’t rise to Papa Bear size, not because it isn’t critically important but because details of the initiative were so sketchy.
Obama is still that same inscrutable man for all seasons, a blank tablet upon which many of us see our own stories written. He said he still wants a health care bill to be passed, and if anyone can tell him a good idea about how to solve the nation’s health care crisis, he wants to hear it. This answer was significantly better than abandoning the issue—a real concern by many going into the speech—but I don’t think it’s going to assuage my activist questioner, and others like her.
Obama would have better served his own agenda by staking out at least one clear line in the sand. But overall, his pitch was just right to allow his presidency to live to fight another day and the porridge of hope continues to nourish the American dream.
Gloria Feldt is author of the War on Choice and currently writing Unlimited, an exploration of women’s relationship with power.





Reader Comments (9)
This is important to perform the correctly done miscellaneous essay and free essays just about this topic to get the excellent mark at the high school.
This is very intersting story post in your article this story on perform Mr. Barak Obama is presently works on the health care. the many type of instruction given on the different-different medical school. thanks for shearing nice or beautiful story.by Politics
are you looking for a air max 2009?
here are not only offer the nike free shoes ,but aslo for thenew lebron VII shoes
President Obama wants to resolve many issues including healthcare, outsourcing with some definite plan. I guess there must be lots of discussion on these issues which were there on his agenda. Personally, i am satisfied with his presidency till now and i hope he will surely make some good reforms in the future.
Thanks for adding this site to one of the many useful sites covering this topic on the net, its successful in its own right and I'll definitely be coming back.
I admire what you have done here. I like the part where you say you are doing this to give back but I would assume by all the comments that this is working for you as well.
By recognizing and addressing discrimination against girls and women, success in the fight against all forms of discrimination -- class, race, ethnicity and age -- will become more likely, and more lasting.
The 2010 FIFA World Cup is right around the corner,nike air max has been releasing footwear to coincide with the world's watched sporting event,Therefore, production of new and different styles of air max shoes,air max nike,the latest air max 2010,nike air max 90,air max 2009,nike air max 87,nike air max 95,nike air max tn,womens air max classic bwand so on,Nike has always prepared a plethora of silhouettes for runners to choose from,and colorways like nike air max 2009 and womens air max 2009 are sure to gain it wider exposure.because this style is very hot sell,nike air max 2009 mesh shoes have mesh quarter panels allow the bearer's feet to breathe,while the midsole sports Nike's patented air max sole.
In this year,nike air max are hot sell,Special nike air max 2009 and nike air max 2010, Air Max technology has been established as a market leader in high-end shoes are known.strange is that their nike air max 90 shoes are all sorts of measures for the consumer-choice’ve. Any brand may be more concerned about what kind of shoes is often the consumer appeal of leading brands in the market.maybe nike air max 95, nike air max classic BW and nike air max TN are best for you!
Good news, nike air max very hot sell,like nike air max 2009,nike air max 2010,air max tailwind,nnike air max leatherr,air max nike shoes,air max 2009,nike air max 2010.in the same time our nike shox shoes
mbt shoes,mbt sandals shoes
mbt kisumu shoes,MBT mens fuaba shoes,MBT mens imara shoes,mbt kisumu shoes,MBT mens sapatu shoes,MBT mens unono shoes,MBT womens tunisha shoes,MBT womens changa shoes,MBT womens ema shoes,MBT womens habari shoes,MBT womens imara shoes,MBT womens kaya shoes,MBT womens kisumu shoes,MBT womens lami shoes,MBT womens panda shoes,MBT womens salama shoes,MBT womens sapatu shoes,MBT womens staka shoes,nike shox dream,nike shox nz,nike shox oz,nike shox R4,nike shox R5,nike shox Torch,nike shox turb,nike shox TL1,nike shox TL3
We see ourselves on a long nike air max 2010 trip that spans the continent. We are traveling by train. Out air max 2009 windows, we drink in the passing scene of cars on nearby highways, of children waving at nike red air max 2009 crossing, of cattle grazing on distant hillside, of smoke pouring from a power plant, of row upon nike air 95 row of corn and wheat, of flatlands and valleys, of mountains and rolling air max 90 hillsides, of city skylines and village halls. But uppermost in our minds is the final destination.